Image: Hayao Miyazaki creating in his studio
The issue of AI generated “art” across various mediums whether animation, visual art, storytelling and music, has been coming up a lot lately. Recently a number of commercial authors through the Author’s Guild US have filed a lawsuit against Meta for sucking up vast numbers of books from platforms featuring pirated books for their large language model AI Llama (the metaphor of AI being a parasite is deliberate!). This has been done with no consideration of legal permissions, intellectual copyright, or compensation to authors. I felt ill reading about how this made author’s feel about their life’s work and creative efforts. Then there has been the inundation across social media of Ghibli AI inspired images that blatantly rips off the aesthetic cultivated over years of creative work of Hayao Miyazaki and Ghibli Studio animators. An interaction has resurfaced as a result from a 2016 documentary on his life, where Miyazaki is shown an AI generated animation of a creepy monster/zombie dragging itself by its head, with the presenter extolling that AI could “present us grotesque movements that we humans can’t imagine”. In response Miyazaki told a story of his friend who has a disability where it was hard for him to raise his arm, so that he found he couldn’t watch this kind of imagery. Miyazaki went on to say: “Whoever creates this stuff has no idea what pain is whatsoever. I am utterly disgusted…I strongly feel this is an insult to life itself.” Miyazaki’s art is deeply human, dealing with universal human concerns, which raises the issue of AI and the very issue of what it means to be human. The brilliant researchers and film makers Aaron and Melissa Dykes at Truthstream Media recently put out a video examining this very nexus of AI, art and human consciousness, What Lies Beyond the Image of Our Humanity?, (click on title to view). I encourage anyone interested in this issue, or is directly impacted by their creative work being sucked into AI models for training or commercial purposes, to watch this and consider the very serious implications of what is happening as AI intersects with human created art.